Biometric, Clinical, Laboratory and Biological Markers of Aging
Core Set of Biomarkers
A biomarker is a measurable feature / marker that has predictive / diagnostic value of a biological state or condition. At this time, one validated, highly relevant and independent biomarker that accurately indicates biological age has not been established. This is due to the complexity of the aging process. For this reason, multiple markers must be employed to accurately inform us of our current age state or BASP.
A fairly recent article provides an excellent road map to produce a core set of markers that will fulfill the requirements described above: “Ranking Biomarkers of Aging by Citation Profiling and Effort Scoring,” ranks markers by their relevance to biological / psychological age, cost and ease of access. The authors of this review article divided the markers into five groups based on that criteria.
The graphic above outlines each category and the thumbnail images below provide clickable access to a detailed spreadsheets for each.
The five sets of markers allow you to select and expand the amount of information you want or are able to obtain. Two scores are provided. The relevance of the marker to biological age: “R-Score and the “E-Score,” which is basically an ease of obtaining each biomarker. Click on the papers icon to read the full text.
• A low e-score (1) describes a potential biomarker which is easy to sample, to handle and to process (usually automated fast and reliable measurements are available from known sources). For example, blood counts from venous blood qualify, since such blood can be sampled easily, the plasma/serum can be stored at room temperature (up to3 h for many analytes) or in a standard freezer (≥3 month for most analytes) and be processed by equipment that is regularly available in a standard diagnostic/clinical unit or research laboratory. The costs are low to moderate (≤10 €).
• A moderate e-score (2) is assigned if one step (sampling, handling, or processing) is associated with substantial extra effort for routine laboratories. This includes sampling under special conditions, a requirement for prompt sample handling, or the need for elaborate validation.
• A high e-score (3) implies elaborate sampling (e.g., biopsy, lumbar puncture, etc.), handling (e.g., storage in liquid nitrogen) and/or processing (e.g., non-routine nucleotide or protein sequencing). The financial costs are usually high.
Brief Description of Each Biomarker by Category
Dedicated pages for each category provides additional information and resources. The overview page provides a list of resources that we have identified to make this process as easy and inexpensive as possible. Click on each icon to enlarge the source spreadsheet or document.
(1) Quality of Life (QOL), Activities of Daily Living (ADL)
QOL is a self administered inventory that allows the individual to evaluate the different components of life that makes that life worthwhile and enjoyable. This includes: social relationships; physical health; ability to perform activities of daily living, and personal circumstances. This process is dependent upon objective assessments of life conditions and subjective assessment of satisfaction, weighted according to the significance an individual places on each particular domain.
A complete description of QOL and a link to download the ARC form is available here.
(2) Biometric Biomarkers
Biometrics are the measurement and statistical analysis of people's unique physical characteristics.
A complete description of Biometric markers and direct links to the resources are available here.
(3) Clinical Physical Capabilities
Tests may include grip strength (described in the above document) or easy to perform locomotor function tests as walking speed, timed up and go test or the standing balance test. As aging is associated with body composition, biomarkers such as BMI or fat and muscle indices should be recorded. Bone mass declines with age in both men and women and may be analyzed. Frequently used other anthropometric markers are muscle mass, waist circumference and (systolic) blood pressure.
(4) Routine Laboratory Biomarkers
A biomarker which is commonly analyzed in accredited laboratories based on standardized methods. It may also help to diagnose, confirm, or exclude a disease. In addition, biomarkers can be prognostic, to determine disease progression, as well as predictive, for monitoring success or failure of some treatment. In this category, cytokines such as interleukins (IL) and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNFα) and other proteins such as C-reactive protein (CRP) belong to the most often mentioned biomarkers of aging.
(5) Research Laboratory Markers (Non-Epigenetic)
A research laboratory biomarker is a laboratory biomarker lacking the routine validation and/or standardization of a clinical laboratory biomarker. These markers often use nucleic acids (DNA and RNA). A frequently discussed biomarker of aging is the telomere length.
(6) Epigenetic Research Laboratory Biomarkers
The epigenome is a dynamic system playing a major role in aging. Methylation of the DNA (DNAm) and histone modifications ensure appropriate high fidelity gene expression; both change with chronological age and with chronic diseases over time. Even if it is currently not known to what extend these changes cause aging, they can be useful, e.g., for chronological age prediction.
Over the next few page each of these categories will be described. The spreadsheets below provide a detailed inventory of each category and includes both there relevance and ease of access scores.
MOVE SECTION BELOW TO NEXT PAGE
The vast majority of individuals are unwilling or unable to repeatedly access markers that can be difficult and expensive to obtain. For that reason we have divided the markers enabling you to determine your BASP into categories that are ranked by relevance, ease of access and cost. Biometric studies such as grip strength and age by visual scan of your face are basically free. As are most clinical markers such as weight, temperature, heart rate and blood pressure. Laboratory markers like complete blood cell count and chemistry panels can be significantly more expensive depending on you insurance and your physicians willingness to prescribe those assays. Epigenetic clocks and telemer lengths can also relatively expensive. Not unlike the targets we identify to regress aging, the markers that effectively inform us of our progress are still being identified, validated and correlated.
Core Set of Biomarkers
A fairly recent article provides an excellent road map to produce a core set of markers that will fulfill the requirements described above: “Ranking Biomarkers of Aging by Citation Profiling and Effort Scoring,” ranks markers by their relevance to biological / psychological age, cost and ease of access. The authors of this review article divided the markers into five groups based on that criteria.
The graphic above outlines each category and the thumbnail images below the graphic, provide clickable access to a detailed spreadsheets for each.
The five sets of markers above 2-6, allow you to select and expand the amount of information you want or are able to obtain. The “E-Score,” is basically an ease of obtaining each biomarker and is scored on a scale of between 1 and 3. The system was adopted from the paper titled: “Ranking Biomarkers of Aging by Citation Profiling and Effort Scoring,” They describe this criteria as:
• A low e-score (1) describes a potential biomarker which is easy to sample, to handle and to process (usually automated fast and reliable measurements are available from known sources). For example, blood counts from venous blood qualify, since such blood can be sampled easily, the plasma/serum can be stored at room temperature (up to3 h for many analytes) or in a standard freezer (≥3 month for most analytes) and be processed by equipment that is regularly available in a standard diagnostic/clinical unit or research laboratory. The costs are low to moderate (≤10 €).
• A moderate e-score (2) is assigned if one step (sampling, handling, or processing) is associated with substantial extra effort for routine laboratories. This includes sampling under special conditions, a requirement for prompt sample handling, or the need for elaborate validation.
• A high e-score (3) implies elaborate sampling (e.g., biopsy, lumbar puncture, etc.), handling (e.g., storage in liquid nitrogen) and/or processing (e.g., non-routine nucleotide or protein sequencing). The financial costs are usually high.
Expanding this core set of markers to include more expensive and more difficult to obtain BASP markers is of course desirable. The more information you have to guide and make decisions the more effective your path to effectively reducing your BASP will be.
Combining all of these markers into a single number representing biological age at a single point in time is a Aagorithmically process that is currentely available online. One published article has pursued that goal for the Laboratory markers described above. “An epigenetic biomarker of aging for lifespan and healthspan.” By entering you lab results into a form, the calculated BASP of an individual is reported. Two sites currentely allow you to access to this process without cost.
Ageless Rx which is a supplement company and
Young.AI a division of Deep Longevity.
Without monitoring your progress, it is impossible to determine if the interventions we are undertaking are safe, effective and positively impacting your BASP. For anyone not involved in an aging clinical trial, accessing these Clinical and biological markers can be both difficult to access and expensive. Our goal is to identify a set of readily available and highly correlated markers that can form a core of effective, affordable, available and stistcically relevant BASP markers.
References:
[1] [2018] An epigenetic biomarker of aging for lifespan and healthspan
Measuring BASP
As we have advocated several times on this site, that your primary care physician should be an active participant in this endeavor. Many of the labs we target below requires your physician to provide script to the laboratory in order to draw them.
Obviously, we want to see the markers move in the opposite direction that historical values normally move. (See: “Correlates of Aging”) If a marker historically increases as we age, we want to see a small but noticeable decrease between our last lab draw and the most recent one. You should note that many of them peak between 65-80 years of age and then begin to decline again. This can produce the false impression that things are improving, when in fact your are seeing the results of normal aging. You should also be aware that many uncontrollable factors can impact these markers. Environmental contaminants; (dust, cigaret smoke, recreational drugs, alcohol, pesticides) emotional state including stress, sleep, mild to severe infections and changes in medications can all cause changes in any or all of the biomarkers we want to monitor. This makes it important that you monitoring protocol is maintained for as long as you are implementing aging interventions.
BASP is the difference between your chronological age, which is intransigent and inevitable, and the physiological / biological age of your immunological systems including organs, cells and chronokines. Clinical and laboratory biological markers are utilized to determine your current BASP.
Environmental factors like pollution, cigarets, alcohol, poor diet and any diseases process will move your BASP higher (older age). Exercise, good diet, meditation, sleep, socialization, friends, lovers, and family moves your BASP down (younger age).
Obviously targeted, biologically active, interventional modalities hold the potential to also regress you BASP. This site is dedicated to finding and optimizing the interventional strategies that safely allow for the reduction of your BASP. Targets of opportunity and agents that effectively and safely regress your BASP are emerging daily.
We have identified a minimal, yet effective set of markers and clinical observations that will provide you with relevant feedback on your progress in regressing you BASP score.
(1) ARC-BASP CORE BIOMARKERS
Expanding this core set of markers to include more expensive and more difficult to obtain BASP markers is of course desirable. The more information you have to guide and make decisions the more effective your path to effectively reducing your BASP will be.
We have provided five sets of markers that allow you to select and expand the amount of information you want or are able to obtain. Each marker is ranked as to its ease and expense of obtaining it and its relevance to effectively determine your BASP score.
The “E-Score,” is basically an ease of obtaining each biomarker and is scored on a scale of between 1 and 3. The system was adopted from the paper titled: “Ranking Biomarkers of Aging by Citation Profiling and Effort Scoring,” They describe this criteria as:
• A low e-score (1) describes a potential biomarker which is easy to sample, to handle and to process (usually automated fast and reliable measurements are available from known sources). For example, blood counts from venous blood qualify, since such blood can be sampled easily, the plasma/serum can be stored at room temperature (up to3 h for many analytes) or in a standard freezer (≥3 month for most analytes) and be processed by equipment that is regularly available in a standard diagnostic/clinical unit or research laboratory. The costs are low to moderate (≤10 €).
• A moderate e-score (2) is assigned if one step (sampling, handling, or processing) is associated with substantial extra effort for routine laboratories. This includes sampling under special conditions, a requirement for prompt sample handling, or the need for elaborate validation.
• A high e-score (3) implies elaborate sampling (e.g., biopsy, lumbar puncture, etc.), handling (e.g., storage in liquid nitrogen) and/or processing (e.g., non-routine nucleotide or protein sequencing). The financial costs are usually high.
Click [√] to Enlarge Image
CLICK [√] to Enlarge
This same group also attempted to provide a relevance score for each marker. This is simply a citation search of all published peer reviewed articles that contained the search criteria shown on the right. The field is moving so fast that some of the scores this process has generated no longer accurately reflect some indicators actual relevance. The authors freely admit that all of their scores are somewhat subjective.
These search results were then further divided into sub-categories. We have produced an excel spreadsheet that contains all of these markers including their RC-Scores and E-Scores that you can download by clicking on the “Excel” link below. We have annotated and added to the indicators provided and in some cases introducing new categories such as age determination by facial recognition. Finally we added our own ranking to denote the most effective and least expensive clinical/biomarkers of aging. Screenshots of each spreadsheet are available by clicking on the icon at the right of each biomarker category.
(1) Clinical, Physical Capability and Organ Function Biomarkers
(2) Routine Laboratory Biomarkers
(3) Research Laboratory Biomarkers (Non-epigenetic)
(4) Research Laboratory Biomarkers based on Epigenetic Measurements
(5) Visual Facial Age Recognition by AI
Complete Excel BioMarkers Spreadsheet is available by clicking on this image: > > >
Horvath’s DNA Methylation BASP Indicators
DNA methylation is a biological process by which methyl groups are added to the DNA molecule. Recent research efforts provided compelling evidence of genome-wide DNA methylation alterations in aging and age-related disease. It is currently well established that DNA methylation biomarkers can determine biological age of any tissue across the entire human lifespan, even during development. [1]
Steve Horvath’s group, using large scale validation data from thousands of individuals, we demonstrate that DNA methylation GrimAge stands out among existing epigenetic clocks in terms of its predictive ability for time-to-death, time-to-coronary heart disease, time-to-cancer, its strong relationship with computed tomography data for fatty liver/excess visceral fat, and age-at-menopause. [2]
DNA methylation has also been suggested as a target in a regressive paradyme. If increased methylation is an indication of age, would a targeted therapy that reduces that methylation levels be an anti-aging intervention?
Laboratory Markers correlating with BASP
Multiple common laboratory markers included in studies like complete blood cell counts and blood chemistry panels also have demonstrated stistcically significant correlations with your BASP vs chronological ages. [3]
Multiple elements of facial recognition age determination. Skin is the largest human organ. Its visibility and accessibility make it a good BASP marker from facial images. There are several biomarkers associated with your eyes that also can contribute to an accurate estimate of your age. AI analysis of your face can produce an accurate indication of your BASP. [4]
[1] DNA Methylation Biomarkers in Aging and Age-Related Diseases
[2] DNA methylation GrimAge strongly predicts lifespan and healthspan
[4]
•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
The primary addressable, interventional BASP targets are detailed in the following paragraph. It would represent the ultimate hubris to assume that this list in any way represents the final word, in both 1) an optimal list of targets, 2) most effective dosage; 3) most effective time of administration; 4) most effective interval of administration; 5) and/or the most effective interventional molecules.
On a personal note I can provide limited (N of 2) feedback on what is described at this point in time. Much like the mice in the Conboy study we have experienced improvements in energy, gastral intestinal function and comfort, memory, concentration and sleep. Our mental outlook has dramatically improved and the feeling of heading toward a cliff that many older individuals experience has abated. Total quality of life is at leat 50% better than prior to implementing this protocol. Activities of daily living have become much easier to accomplish. This work will continue for many years fine tuning the optimal age-regression protocol. You own contribution to this information is critical.
If the word is bolded and underscored it is included in our inventory of supplemental interventions.
1) Increasing levels of TGF-beta-1 are correlated with increasing age[4]. The Conboys in the referenced paper describe it as: “age-related elevation in the intensity of this pathway may contribute to diminished stem cell regeneration in the hippocampal niche, which combined with our prior results with the skeletal muscle stem cell niche would demonstrate conservation of signal transduction changes with age.” ALK5 provides an effective and very druggable target that results in the downregulation or inhibition of TGF-beta-1 signaling. Supplements able to inhibit ALK5 include EGEC, Fiesten, Qcertain, and Curcumin. Resveratrol [1] an Petrostilbene[] inhibit the signaling downstream from ALK5 at pSmad 2,3.
2) Levels of the hormone Oxytocin decline with age.
Oxytocin can be up-regulated by the administration of several forms of Oxytocin now available online.
Oxytocin can be up-regulated by multiple supplements including:
3) AKG is a required intermediary in the Krebs cycle. It also facilitates the assembly and transportation of many of the bodies building blocks; amino-acids. Multiple studies in multiple animal models have documented an increased life-span resulting from AKG supplementation.
4) Glutathione is an important component of cellular metabolism and energy production. A recent paper described how the supplementation with N-acetylcysteine (NAC), and Glycine increased intercellular glutathione, producing dramatic and sustained improvements in multiple measurements, leading to an improved quality of life. This included improved glutathione deficiency, oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, inflammation, insulin resistance, endothelial dysfunction, genotoxicity, muscle strength, and cognition. [2] Another research group accomplished similar results providing only Lyophilized Glutathione as the interventional supplementation [3]. 5) Leucine has demonstrated in multiple studies a longevity benefit [4]. Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA). Vitamin D is expected to be a primary anti-aging medicine in the near future due to its numerous positive effects in the elderly population.
5) Down regulation of IL-6.
IL-6, perhaps considered one of the first aging biomarkers, was described as “a cytokine for gerontologists” (Ershler, 1993). IL-6 is the best characterized biomarker for “inflammaging,” a chronic low-grade inflammation that develops with advanced age and contributes to the pathogenesis of age-related diseases and most recently has been recognized as a core element of the secretome produced by senescent cells (Lopez-Otin et al., 2013; Ferrucci and Fabbri, 2018; Franceschi et al., 2018). High circulating levels of proinflammatory cytokines, such as IL-6 have been associated both cross-sectionally and prospectively with major age-related chronic diseases as well as with disability and frailty (Maggio et al., 2013). Insulin-like Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1 (IGF 1), which contributes to the decline of muscle strength with aging (Maggio et al., 2013; Johnson et al., 2020; Moaddel et al., 2021)
As the age increased by 1 year, IL-6 values increased by 0.05 pg/ml (95% CI: 0.02, 0.09; p < .01) [5].
REFERENCES:
[1] 2014 Activation of SIRT3 by resveratrol ameliorates cardiac fibrosis and improvescardiac function via the TGF-!/Smad3 pathway
[2] 2021 Glycine and N-acetylcysteine (GlyNAC) supplementation in older adults improves glutathione deficiency, oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, inflammation, insulin resistance, endothelial dysfunction, genotoxicity, muscle strength, and cognition: Results of a pilot clinical trial
[3] 2018 Oral supplementation with liposomal glutathione elevates body stores of glutathione and markers of immune function
[4] 2011 Low-dose lithium uptake promotes longevity in humans and metazoans
[5] 2021 Defining IL-6 levels in healthy individuals: A meta-analysis
Next page in chronology
A small targeted and inexpensive set of biomarkers to monitor your BASP